Chanakya IAS Academy Blog

Introduction The article discuss talks about the India’s refusal to Google’s Street View service and experiences of other countries.

  • There is little that is surprising about India’s recent refusal to allow Google to launch its Street View service, which gives users a 360-degree view of public spaces.
  • The proposal was rejected following objections raised by the Defence Ministry.
  • The decision is said to have come in the backdrop of the terror attack on the Pathankot airbase in January, with investigators suspecting that terrorists used Google Maps to study the topography of the targeted area.
  • Street View goes a step further than the maps. It displays panoramic views of public spaces, thanks to images captured by Google’s moving vehicles, adding a layer of depth and reality to the maps.
  • India has hinted that its refusal is not final and that such issues could be resolved once the Geospatial Bill, which seeks to regulate map-creation and sharing, comes into force.

Objections by other countries:

  • India isn’t the first country to seem troubled by Street View. Since its launch in 2007 in the U.S., the service has faced roadblocks in many countries.
  • In the U.S., for instance, both the Department of Homeland Security and the Department of Defense had concerns over Google capturing images of sensitive locations.
  • In Europe, especially Germany, concerns over loss of privacy took centre stage.
  • The script wasn’t different in Japan.

Solutions found:

  • The service figured out a way to blur people’s faces and licence plates automatically before the pictures were made public.
  • In the U.S., Google was asked to remove sensitive information, and its image-capturing cars were ordered to keep off military bases.
  • In Germany, households were given the option of blurring their buildings.
  • In Japan, the height from which the cameras scanned the neighbourhoods was lowered and local governments were notified prior to Google’s photography.
  • Even Israel, which takes internal security very seriously, gave the green signal to Street View five years ago, reportedly making sure Google doesn’t show images in real-time and only photographs public spaces open to all.

Its benefits:

  • While there is an obvious tourism angle involved, Google representatives have spoken of Street View’s usefulness in disaster management.
  • All things considered, it might not be in India’s best interests to keep out this technology for long.

    Question:Technology is not only used for common good but it is also used by non state actors as was the case in recent terrorist attack on Pathankot Airbase. Where the location viewing technology is alleged to have been used. But that does not mean we don’t use it all altogether as is the case with Google’s Street view service in India. Examine.

    Suggested Approach:

    1. Security issues with Google’s Street View technology.
    2. Its benefits.
    3. How other countries have tackled such issues.
    4. Your view point whether we should use it or not.

    Link: http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/editorial/editorial-on-indias-refusal-to-allow-google-to-launch-street-view/article8737705.ece

    English: Download

    Hindi: Download

Read 501 times Last modified on Monday, 11 July 2016 18:20
Login to post comments